Oleksandr Usyk has already achieved more in professional boxing than most fighters could ever dream of.
He’s conquered the cruiserweight division, become undisputed heavyweight champion, defeated some of the biggest names of his generation and maintained an undefeated professional record.
At 39, the Ukrainian has nothing left to prove.
Yet rather than walking away from boxing with his remarkable legacy intact, Usyk is reportedly considering another ambitious challenge.
According to Boxing News, his team is exploring a two-fight return to cruiserweight in 2027, with the ultimate objective of facing David Benavidez for the undisputed world championship.
On paper, it’s an extraordinary ambition.
But I can’t help wondering whether it’s also an unnecessary gamble.
Because while Oleksandr Usyk has spent his career proving people wrong, there comes a point when even the greatest fighters must ask themselves whether another achievement is worth the potential consequences.
And after what happened against Rico Verhoeven earlier this year, I think that’s a question Usyk needs to consider very carefully.
Oleksandr Usyk Is Targeting Another Undisputed Championship
According to a report published by Boxing News on 30 October, Usyk’s adviser Sergey Lapin has outlined a potential two-fight plan for 2027.
The first objective would be to return to cruiserweight and challenge for the vacant IBF world championship.
From there, the intention would be to face David Benavidez in a contest that could determine the undisputed champion, provided the remaining titles are brought together.
It’s certainly an ambitious proposal.
Benavidez has already established himself as one of boxing’s most dangerous fighters, having moved up to cruiserweight and captured the WBA and WBO titles with a sixth-round stoppage victory over Gilberto Ramirez.
He’s also targeting further championship opportunities within the division.
For Usyk, the attraction is obvious.
Becoming undisputed cruiserweight champion again, having already conquered the heavyweight division, would add another remarkable chapter to an extraordinary career.
But there’s an important distinction between wanting to achieve something and genuinely needing to achieve it.
And that’s where I begin to question this particular ambition.
What Does Usyk Actually Have Left to Prove?
When discussing Oleksandr Usyk, it’s worth remembering just how much he’s already accomplished.
He became undisputed cruiserweight champion during an era featuring outstanding fighters such as Mairis Briedis and Murat Gassiev.
He then moved into the heavyweight division, where many questioned whether his size would prevent him from competing against the very best.
Instead, he defeated Anthony Joshua twice, overcame Tyson Fury twice and established himself as the outstanding heavyweight of his generation.
He also defeated Daniel Dubois twice, further strengthening his position among boxing’s elite.
These weren’t carefully selected opponents designed to protect an undefeated record.
They were genuine challenges against world-class fighters.
Usyk took those risks, answered the questions and earned his place among the greatest fighters of the modern era.
So what exactly would another undisputed cruiserweight championship prove?
That he can compete at the highest level in the division?
We already know that.
That he’s technically superior to most fighters in the world?
He’s demonstrated that repeatedly.
That he’s one of boxing’s greatest champions?
Surely that argument has already been settled.
Another undisputed championship would undoubtedly strengthen his historical achievements.
But I struggle to believe it would fundamentally change how his career should be remembered.
And that makes the potential risks considerably harder to justify.
The Rico Verhoeven Fight Should Be a Warning
One of the reasons I’m particularly concerned about Oleksandr Usyk continuing his career is what happened against Rico Verhoeven in May.
Before that contest, I expected Usyk to win relatively comfortably.
Verhoeven was an outstanding kickboxer, but he had very limited experience in professional boxing.
Against someone with Usyk’s technical ability, experience and accomplishments, that should have been a significant disadvantage.
Instead, Verhoeven gave the Ukrainian considerably more trouble than most people anticipated.
Usyk eventually secured an eleventh-round stoppage victory, but the circumstances surrounding that result raised legitimate questions.
Two judges had the contest level after ten rounds, while the third had Verhoeven ahead.
The stoppage itself was controversial.
Now, I’m not suggesting that one difficult performance means Usyk is suddenly finished.
That would be ridiculous.
Great fighters can have difficult nights, and Verhoeven deserves considerable credit for the problems he created.
But we cannot simply ignore what happened because Usyk ultimately got his hand raised.
I previously discussed the questions surrounding that contest and whether Verhoeven deserved another opportunity against the Ukrainian.
My concern now goes beyond whether Verhoeven should receive a rematch.
If Oleksandr Usyk struggled to impose himself against an opponent with so little professional boxing experience, what happens when he faces someone like David Benavidez?
Benavidez is younger, aggressive, technically accomplished and accustomed to competing against elite professional boxers.
He’s not going to enter the ring simply hoping to survive against a legendary champion.
He’ll be looking to establish himself at Usyk’s expense.
And while Usyk might still possess the skills necessary to defeat him, I don’t believe we should automatically assume he’s the same fighter who dominated the cruiserweight division years ago.
Time eventually catches up with everyone.
Even the very best.
Can Oleksandr Usyk Safely Return to Cruiserweight at 39?
There’s another issue that I believe deserves considerably more attention.
The weight.
Oleksandr Usyk spent years competing at cruiserweight before moving up to heavyweight.
Since then, his body has adapted to facing substantially larger opponents.
For his contest against Rico Verhoeven, Usyk weighed approximately 233 pounds.
The cruiserweight limit is 200 pounds.
That represents a potential reduction of around 33 pounds if he returns at a similar starting weight.
Now, that doesn’t necessarily mean Usyk would need to lose every pound through an aggressive weight cut.
A carefully managed training programme could allow him to reduce his weight gradually over several months.
His team would also have access to experienced nutritionists and conditioning specialists.
But let’s not pretend that makes the transition straightforward.
At 39, Usyk would be asking his body to undergo another substantial transformation after years of demanding training camps and championship contests.
Losing weight is one thing.
Losing weight while preserving strength, stamina, punch resistance and recovery is something entirely different.
And those qualities become increasingly important when facing younger opponents who are naturally comfortable competing at cruiserweight.
There’s also the question of how his body would respond to returning to a division he left years ago.
Would the weight reduction affect his endurance?
Could it compromise his physical resilience?
Would he still possess the same movement and reactions that made him so difficult to defeat?
Nobody can answer those questions with certainty until the process begins.
And that’s precisely why I believe this proposed return carries unnecessary risk.
David Benavidez Would Be a Dangerous Opponent
If Oleksandr Usyk does return to cruiserweight, a potential meeting with David Benavidez would undoubtedly attract enormous attention.
It’s the sort of contest boxing supporters would naturally find fascinating.
An undefeated legend attempting to reclaim his former division against a younger champion determined to establish his own greatness.
But from Usyk’s perspective, I struggle to see the balance between risk and reward.
Benavidez would enter such a contest with youth on his side.
He would also have the opportunity to defeat one of the most accomplished fighters of his generation.
For Benavidez, the potential reward would be enormous.
A victory over Usyk would immediately become one of the defining achievements of his career.
For Usyk, the situation is different.
Winning would add another historic accomplishment to an already extraordinary record.
Losing wouldn’t erase what he’s achieved, but it would raise uncomfortable questions about whether he should have continued competing.
More importantly, there’s the possibility of suffering a physically damaging defeat.
And that’s the part of this discussion I believe matters far more than preserving an undefeated record.
Because a fighter’s health should always be more important than another championship belt.
Motivation Matters More Than Another World Title
I’ve always believed that one of the most dangerous situations in boxing is when a fighter continues competing without a clear reason for doing so.
That doesn’t mean every boxer needs to retire once they’ve made enough money or won enough championships.
If someone genuinely loves competing, remains physically capable and has a meaningful objective, there’s nothing inherently wrong with continuing.
But there has to be a purpose.
And it needs to be a purpose strong enough to justify the sacrifices involved.
That’s why I’d be interested to know what is genuinely motivating Oleksandr Usyk.
Is he determined to become undisputed cruiserweight champion again because he believes there’s unfinished business?
Does he see an opportunity to accomplish something that would make his career even more historically significant?
Or has he simply identified another challenge because he isn’t quite ready to stop?
Those are very different motivations.
And although nobody outside Usyk’s inner circle can know exactly what he’s thinking, I believe the distinction matters.
Boxing isn’t a sport where you can afford to compete without complete commitment.
Training camps are physically demanding.
Weight management can be exhausting.
And once the opening bell rings, an opponent isn’t going to show any sympathy because you’re approaching 40 or have already achieved greatness.
If Usyk genuinely believes he can return to cruiserweight and dominate the division, then he has every right to pursue that ambition.
But if the motivation is simply to find another mountain to climb, I’d question whether the potential reward justifies the danger.
Especially when he’s already reached the summit so many times.
Would One Defeat Really Damage Usyk’s Legacy?
There’s a tendency in boxing to place enormous importance on undefeated records.
Floyd Mayweather’s perfect professional record is frequently used as evidence of his greatness.
Meanwhile, fighters who suffered defeats are sometimes judged more harshly, regardless of the quality of their opposition or the circumstances surrounding those losses.
Personally, I’ve never believed an undefeated record should be the defining measure of a fighter’s career.
Muhammad Ali lost fights.
Sugar Ray Leonard lost fights.
Roberto Duran lost fights.
Nobody seriously believes those defeats erase their achievements.
The same principle should apply to Oleksandr Usyk.
If he returned to cruiserweight and lost to David Benavidez, it wouldn’t suddenly invalidate everything he accomplished against Joshua, Fury, Dubois or the leading cruiserweights of his era.
His achievements would remain extraordinary.
But that doesn’t mean another defeat would be meaningless.
There’s a difference between losing while pursuing greatness and continuing to compete after your physical abilities have begun to decline.
One can enhance a fighter’s reputation for courage.
The other can leave supporters wondering why someone with so much already achieved felt the need to take another risk.
And while boxing history would eventually remember Usyk’s greatest victories, the physical consequences of another demanding campaign could remain with him long after his career ends.
That’s what concerns me.
Not the possibility of losing his undefeated record.
The possibility of sacrificing something considerably more important in pursuit of an achievement he doesn’t actually need.
Knowing When to Walk Away Is Also a Form of Greatness
Boxing supporters spend enormous amounts of time discussing what makes a fighter great.
Championships.
Victories.
Opposition.
Longevity.
Technical ability.
But perhaps we don’t spend enough time considering the importance of knowing when to stop.
There are countless examples of legendary fighters who continued competing long after their finest performances.
Some were motivated by money.
Others believed they could still compete at the highest level.
And some simply struggled to accept that their careers were approaching an end.
I’m not suggesting Oleksandr Usyk has reached that point.
He’s still undefeated, and even his difficult victory over Verhoeven demonstrated his ability to find a way through adversity.
But I do believe the warning signs deserve consideration.
He’s approaching 40.
He’s spent years competing against much larger opponents.
He’s already conquered two weight divisions.
And now he’s contemplating another significant weight reduction before potentially facing one of boxing’s most dangerous younger champions.
At some point, surely the question has to change.
Instead of asking what else Oleksandr Usyk can achieve, perhaps we should ask what else he actually needs to achieve.
Because the answer might be nothing.
Oleksandr Usyk Has Earned the Right to Walk Away
I understand why another undisputed cruiserweight championship would appeal to Oleksandr Usyk.
He’s spent his entire career accepting challenges that other fighters might have avoided.
That ambition is part of what has made him such an extraordinary champion.
And if he successfully returns to cruiserweight and defeats David Benavidez, it would be another remarkable achievement.
But I don’t believe every challenge is worth accepting simply because it’s there.
Usyk has already established himself as one of the greatest fighters of his generation.
His accomplishments at cruiserweight and heavyweight speak for themselves.
He doesn’t need another world title to justify his place in boxing history.
And after his surprisingly difficult contest against Rico Verhoeven, I believe there are legitimate reasons to question whether another prolonged campaign is the right decision.
Ultimately, only Usyk and his team can determine whether his body remains capable of handling the demands of elite competition.
But from where I’m sitting, the potential reward simply doesn’t outweigh the risks.
Oleksandr Usyk has already climbed boxing’s highest mountains.
Perhaps the greatest achievement left isn’t reaching another summit.
Perhaps it’s recognising that he’s already done enough.
What Do You Think? Should Usyk Chase History or Protect His Legacy?
Would you like to see Oleksandr Usyk return to cruiserweight and challenge David Benavidez for another undisputed championship?
Or do you believe his difficult performance against Rico Verhoeven suggests it’s time to consider retirement?
And most importantly, is another world title really worth the physical risks at this stage of his career?
I’d love to hear your thoughts.
Share your opinion in the comments below, whether you agree with me or think Usyk still has another historic achievement waiting for him.
And if you enjoy independent boxing opinions, honest analysis and discussions about the biggest issues facing the sport, visit CMBoxing for more articles.
Because boxing is about more than what happens between the opening and final bells.