There is a difference between being the A-side in boxing and being allowed to call every shot.
That distinction matters when we talk about Claressa Shields vs Lauren Price.
Nobody can seriously dispute that Shields is the bigger global name. She has earned enormous commercial influence through an extraordinary career, and if negotiations reflect that status, nobody should be particularly surprised.
But negotiations are supposed to involve two sides.
Right now, the potential terms surrounding Shields against Price appear remarkably favourable to one of them.
Price is willing to move from welterweight towards the middleweight limit to make the fight. Previous discussions have centred on the first contest taking place in America. And while no purse split has been announced, it would hardly be surprising if Shields’ greater commercial profile resulted in her receiving the larger financial share as well.
Think about what that could mean.
Shields gets the weight.
Shields gets the location.
And Shields could quite reasonably get the bigger payday.
So what exactly is Lauren Price getting from the negotiation?
If Price is prepared to make the biggest sporting concession required to make Claressa Shields vs Lauren Price happen, I think Shields should make one concession of her own.
Come to Wales.
Lauren Price Is Taking the Sporting Risk
This should be the starting point of the entire discussion.
Price is not a middleweight world champion asking Shields to defend against her.
She is The Ring, WBA, WBC and IBF welterweight champion.
Her professional career has been built at 147lb.
Shields, meanwhile, has returned to middleweight and reclaimed the WBA and WBC titles after stopping Kaye Scott in six rounds.
Yes, Price has fought at higher weights as an amateur. She won Olympic gold at 75kg in Tokyo, so she isn’t suddenly entering completely unfamiliar physical territory.
But professional boxing is different.
Price has established herself professionally as an elite welterweight. If she moves towards 160lb to challenge Shields, she is giving away something that could directly influence what happens when the bell rings.
Size.
Shields has operated comfortably at middleweight and considerably beyond it. She has won world titles across multiple divisions, including at heavyweight.
Price is prepared to enter her territory.
That matters far more to me than which country hosts the fight.
Being the A-Side Doesn’t Mean Getting Everything
None of this is an argument against Shields’ status.
Quite the opposite.
Shields is a two-time Olympic gold medallist, has won world titles across five weight divisions and has become undisputed champion in three.
Her claim to being the greatest female boxer of all time is not simply marketing.
I recently looked at Shields’ return to middleweight and asked what meaningful challenges remain after everything she has already achieved:
Price is interesting precisely because she represents something Shields increasingly needs: an unbeaten champion with genuine pedigree who believes she can beat her.
Shields has earned the right to negotiate from a position of strength.
But there is a point where negotiating from a position of strength starts looking like the other fighter is being expected to concede everything.
Price moves up.
Price travels.
And if Shields receives the larger purse because she is the bigger commercial attraction, Price potentially accepts the financial hierarchy as well.
Being the A-side should give Shields leverage. It shouldn’t mean Price has to surrender the weight, the location and potentially the biggest slice of the money as well.
We Don’t Know the Money – And That’s Important
Let’s be clear about something before going any further.
We do not know what either fighter would be paid.
There is no confirmed purse split for Claressa Shields vs Lauren Price, and it would be wrong to present one as though there were.
Shields might receive substantially more. The split could be closer than expected. There could be guarantees, percentages and other commercial arrangements that completely change the picture.
We simply don’t know.
But if Shields does receive the larger share, I wouldn’t have a problem with that.
She is the bigger international star.
Boxing isn’t a charity and purse negotiations are based on commercial value as much as sporting achievement.
My problem would be if Price is expected to accept the financial position of the B-side while simultaneously accepting every other disadvantage that comes with it.
If Shields gets paid like the A-side and gets the weight she wants, why does she need home advantage as well?
At some point, Price’s side should be entitled to put something meaningful on their side of the negotiating table.
Wales should be it.
Price Makes the Dangerous Concession – Shields Makes the Inconvenient One
This is ultimately what the argument comes down to for me.
Moving up in weight is a sporting concession.
Travelling is a logistical concession.
They aren’t the same thing.
Price would potentially be fighting a naturally bigger woman who has competed several divisions above her.
That affects the punches.
It affects physical strength.
It affects clinches.
It affects whether Price can impose herself physically when the fight becomes difficult.
Shields travelling to Cardiff means dealing with a hostile crowd, unfamiliar surroundings and not having the comfort of fighting at home.
Those things matter.
But they don’t make Price punch harder.
Price isn’t asking Shields to make the dangerous concession. She’s asking her to make the inconvenient one.
That seems a perfectly reasonable trade.
Shields gets the weight.
Price gets Wales.
Now we have something resembling a negotiation.
Forget the Rematch – Put the First Fight in Wales
Price has previously spoken about travelling to America first before potentially bringing a second fight back to Wales.
I understand the logic.
I just don’t think she should have to do it.
Boxing has become far too comfortable selling hypothetical rematches before the first fight has even happened.
There is no guarantee we ever get Fight Two.
Suppose Shields wins decisively.
Suppose Price wins decisively.
Suppose somebody gets injured.
Suppose promotional relationships change.
Suppose another major opportunity becomes available.
Suppose one fighter simply decides she doesn’t need to do it again.
Suddenly, the great Welsh homecoming everybody was promised disappears.
If Wales deserves one Claressa Shields vs Lauren Price fight, why shouldn’t it get the first one?
Make the biggest event possible while the opportunity actually exists.
Put It in the Principality Stadium
And if we’re going to Wales, don’t think small.
The Principality Stadium — still the Millennium Stadium to plenty of us — is exactly the kind of stage this fight deserves.
Think about what you’re selling.
Two Olympic gold medallists.
Two unbeaten professional champions.
One of the greatest female boxers ever.
The biggest active name in Welsh boxing.
Price moving up in weight.
Shields entering hostile territory.
America against Wales.
There is your promotion.
You don’t need to manufacture some ridiculous personal hatred between them.
You don’t need overturned tables.
You don’t need somebody’s entourage starting a pushing match at every press conference.
You don’t even particularly need the fighters to dislike each other.
Can Lauren Price move up in weight and beat the GWOAT in Wales?
That’s the story.
Sell that.
Yes, I Think It Would Sell
There will inevitably be questions about whether Claressa Shields vs Lauren Price is big enough for the Principality Stadium.
I think it is.
Of course, putting a fight inside a stadium and actually filling it are two very different things.
But boxing sometimes becomes so obsessed with asking whether women’s boxing can sell enormous venues that it forgets the obvious question:
How are we ever going to find its ceiling if nobody tests it?
Price gives the event its Welsh identity.
Shields gives it international significance.
Then build the undercard properly.
Put Welsh fighters on it. Put major British talent underneath the main event. Make it feel like a national sporting occasion rather than simply another world championship card that happens to be taking place in Cardiff.
The ingredients are already there.
And frankly, I don’t think this fight requires an extraordinary amount of promotional creativity.
The names and circumstances do most of the work.
Lauren Price. Claressa Shields. Cardiff.
Sometimes boxing doesn’t need to make things complicated.
Shields Has Already Proved She Can Travel
There is another reason I don’t buy the argument that Shields needs America.
She’s already demonstrated that she doesn’t.
Savannah Marshall had something no other professional opponent could claim when Shields travelled to London to face her in 2022.
She had beaten Shields.
Yes, it happened in the amateurs, but that defeat followed Shields throughout her professional career.
Then Shields came to Britain, entered an arena overwhelmingly supporting Marshall and beat her.
It strengthened her legacy.
Cardiff could offer another version of that challenge.
Imagine Shields walking towards the ring inside the Principality Stadium with tens of thousands of Welsh supporters desperately wanting her to lose.
Imagine that atmosphere.
Imagine Price standing in the opposite corner carrying the expectations of an entire country.
And then imagine Shields beating her anyway.
If Shields genuinely wants to strengthen her argument that she is the GWOAT, why wouldn’t she want nights like that?
Greatness isn’t only about collecting belts.
Sometimes it’s about where you went to collect them.
Women’s Boxing Should Be Chasing These Occasions
There is a wider issue here that goes beyond Shields and Price.
Women’s boxing has spent years smashing through ceilings people insisted existed.
Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano proved women could headline Madison Square Garden.
Shields and Marshall demonstrated the scale that a major women’s fight could achieve in Britain.
The next stage shouldn’t simply be making more women’s world-title fights.
It should be creating enormous women’s boxing events.
There is a difference.
A major fight in an American arena could be successful.
Claressa Shields vs Lauren Price at the Principality Stadium could be memorable.
Boxing should occasionally choose the location that adds the most to the story rather than automatically putting the fight wherever the biggest star happens to come from.
This feels like exactly that kind of fight.
Shields Gets the Weight. Price Gets Wales.
That’s where I land on Claressa Shields vs Lauren Price.
This isn’t about disrespecting Shields.
It isn’t pretending Price has the same global profile.
And it certainly isn’t suggesting Shields should surrender everything she has earned through one of the greatest careers in women’s boxing history.
It’s about compromise.
If Shields’ commercial status earns her the larger payday, fair enough.
If Price wants the fight badly enough to move up towards middleweight, she accepts that sporting challenge.
But Shields shouldn’t then automatically get the venue as well.
Shields gets paid like the A-side.
Shields gets the weight of the A-side.
Why does she need the home advantage of the A-side as well?
Price makes the dangerous concession.
Shields makes the inconvenient one.
160lb. Principality Stadium. Cardiff.
That sounds like a negotiation.
More importantly, it sounds like an occasion.
Claressa Shields has earned the right to call herself the GWOAT.
Now give her tens of thousands of Welsh fans, an unbeaten Olympic champion standing across the ring and an entire stadium hoping she gets beaten.
If she walks through all of that and wins anyway?
That’s another reason to call her great.
Your Corner – Who Should Give Ground?
If Lauren Price is willing to move up in weight for Claressa Shields vs Lauren Price, should Shields agree to bring the fight to Wales?
And if Shields is also likely to command the greater financial reward as the bigger global name, is asking Price to travel to America a concession too far?
Share this article, leave your opinion in the comments and tell me how you would negotiate the fight.
For more independent boxing opinion, analysis and discussion, visit CMBoxing.