Carlos Adames Criticises Gerome Warburton – But Was Survival Really a Failure?

Carlos Adames vs Gerome Warburton CMBoxing illustration questioning Adames's criticism of Warburton for surviving ten rounds in Riyadh.

Carlos Adames vs Gerome Warburton ended with a comfortable unanimous decision victory for the WBC middleweight champion in Riyadh. However, rather than simply acknowledging his victory, Adames decided to criticise his opponent for seemingly concentrating on survival rather than attempting to win.

And I’ve got a problem with that.

If Carlos Adames genuinely believes he was so much better than Gerome Warburton, why didn’t he finish the job?

We’re talking about an established world champion facing a fighter with considerably less experience at the highest level. Yet, after ten rounds, Warburton was still standing.

So who should we really be criticising?

Gerome Warburton for surviving, or Carlos Adames for failing to stop him?

Before Adames starts criticising his opponents, perhaps he should take a closer look at his own performance.

Carlos Adames vs Gerome Warburton: What Did We Really Expect?

Nobody was seriously suggesting that Gerome Warburton was operating at the same level as Carlos Adames heading into their contest in Riyadh.

Adames is an established world champion. Warburton was taking an enormous step up in opposition against one of the best middleweights in the world.

The difference in experience, achievement and technical ability was considerable.

For Warburton, this was an opportunity to share the ring with a world-class fighter and discover exactly where he stood.

Unfortunately, the answer became apparent fairly quickly.

Adames was comfortably the better boxer, and Warburton struggled to find a way into the contest.

But does that mean Warburton should have abandoned his defensive approach and started taking unnecessary risks simply to satisfy the world champion?

Absolutely not.

If anything, the fact that Warburton managed to complete ten rounds against a fighter of Adames’s calibre deserves some recognition.

What’s Wrong With a Boxer Wanting to Survive?

There seems to be an attitude amongst some boxing supporters that a fighter should continue chasing victory regardless of how unrealistic that prospect becomes.

It sounds admirable.

It also completely ignores the realities of professional boxing.

There’s absolutely nothing wrong with a boxer recognising that he cannot realistically win a contest and deciding that his priority is reaching the final bell.

That doesn’t mean he should stop competing altogether. Nor does it mean he should deliberately refuse to engage.

However, it does mean he’s entitled to adjust his approach to protect himself.

What would people have preferred to see from Warburton?

Would they have been happier if he’d abandoned his defence, stood directly in front of Adames and suffered a brutal knockout?

Would that somehow have made him a better fighter?

Of course not.

It would simply have given Adames the spectacular finish he apparently wanted.

And here’s the thing.

Gerome Warburton wasn’t there to make Carlos Adames look good.

He was there to box.

If Adames wanted a knockout, it was his responsibility to earn one.

If Carlos Adames Was That Good, Why Didn’t He Get the Stoppage?

This is the question I keep coming back to following Carlos Adames vs Gerome Warburton.

Adames has criticised Warburton for concentrating on survival, but surely a world champion should possess the ability to break down a defensive opponent?

If the difference in class was as considerable as Adames appears to believe, why was Warburton still standing at the final bell?

You cannot spend ten rounds demonstrating your superiority, fail to secure a stoppage and then place all the responsibility for that failure on your opponent.

Breaking down a defensive fighter is part of professional boxing.

It’s about cutting off the ring, changing the angles, varying your attacks, working the body and creating opportunities.

It’s about finding solutions when an opponent refuses to give you the openings you want.

That’s what separates good fighters from exceptional ones.

I’ve previously discussed the importance of body punching and why it remains one of boxing’s most underrated skills:

If an opponent is concentrating on protecting his head and avoiding exchanges, attacking the body and applying intelligent pressure can be effective ways of breaking down that resistance.

Adames had ten rounds to find a solution.

He didn’t.

That doesn’t make him a bad fighter, and there’s certainly nothing wrong with winning a comfortable unanimous decision.

But if he’s disappointed that he couldn’t secure a stoppage, perhaps he should be asking himself why.

Blaming Warburton is the easy option.

A World Champion Isn’t Entitled to a Knockout

One of the things that frustrates me about Adames’s criticism is the apparent expectation that Warburton should have fought in a way that suited him.

Why should he?

Boxing isn’t a sport in which opponents are required to accommodate each other’s preferred fighting styles.

If you’re a dangerous puncher, your opponent is perfectly entitled to avoid standing in front of you.

If you’re an aggressive pressure fighter, your opponent is perfectly entitled to use movement to frustrate you.

And if you’re a world champion facing somebody determined to reach the final bell, it’s your responsibility to find a way through their defence.

Imagine if every fighter who struggled to break down a defensive opponent simply blamed that opponent for not engaging enough.

We’d spend half our time listening to boxers complain about why their opponents wouldn’t let them land punches.

The greatest fighters adapt.

They don’t expect their opponents to make life easier for them.

Carlos Adames vs Gerome Warburton demonstrated that Adames was the superior fighter, but it also demonstrated that Warburton could frustrate him sufficiently to prevent a stoppage.

Surely that’s something Adames should be examining rather than complaining about?

Defensive Boxing Isn’t Something We Should Apologise For

Regular readers of CMBoxing will know that I’ve long believed defensive boxing doesn’t receive anywhere near enough recognition.

I’ve discussed that subject in greater detail here:

We celebrate knockouts, aggressive fighters and spectacular combinations.

Yet when somebody demonstrates the ability to avoid being stopped by a dangerous opponent, we often dismiss their performance as negative.

There is, of course, a difference between effective defensive boxing and simply surviving.

A fighter who offers virtually nothing offensively cannot reasonably expect to win rounds.

Warburton didn’t do enough to make his contest with Adames genuinely competitive, and that’s a perfectly legitimate criticism.

But that doesn’t mean his defensive work had no value.

The ability to recognise danger, avoid punches and prevent a superior opponent from securing a stoppage is still a boxing skill.

It might not win you a world championship.

It might not entertain everybody watching.

But it’s considerably more intelligent than allowing yourself to absorb unnecessary punishment simply because your opponent wants a knockout.

Would We Be Having This Conversation If Warburton Had Been Knocked Out?

Imagine for a moment that Gerome Warburton had decided to abandon his defensive approach halfway through the contest.

He starts taking risks, exchanging punches and leaving himself exposed.

Adames catches him with a devastating combination and stops him.

What would the reaction have been?

We’d probably have been discussing whether Warburton should ever have been in the ring with Carlos Adames in the first place.

People would have questioned the matchmaking, the difference in ability and whether the Welshman’s team had taken an unnecessary risk with his career.

Yet because Warburton managed to avoid that outcome, he’s being criticised for surviving.

He seemingly couldn’t win either way.

And that highlights one of the contradictions within boxing.

We talk about fighter safety, protecting boxers and avoiding unnecessary punishment.

Then, when a fighter makes decisions that help him avoid unnecessary punishment, some people criticise him for lacking ambition.

You cannot have it both ways.

Perhaps the Matchmaking Deserves More Criticism

If Carlos Adames vs Gerome Warburton was such a one-sided contest that the world champion felt his opponent was doing little more than surviving, perhaps we should be questioning why the fight was made in the first place.

Warburton accepted an opportunity to face a world champion.

I certainly won’t criticise him for that.

Professional boxing careers are relatively short, and opportunities to share the ring with elite fighters don’t come along every day.

However, accepting an opportunity and being ready for that opportunity are two completely different things.

Was Warburton genuinely prepared for such a substantial step up?

Did the matchmakers realistically believe he possessed the tools to trouble Adames?

Or was this always likely to be a contest in which the world champion dominated proceedings?

If Adames wanted an opponent capable of pushing him, testing his abilities and forcing him into competitive exchanges, perhaps he should have been facing somebody closer to his own level.

It seems rather unfair to criticise Warburton for failing to provide a competitive contest when the difference in experience and achievement was apparent before the opening bell.

Gerome Warburton Has Nothing to Be Ashamed Of

I’m not suggesting that Warburton delivered a brilliant performance.

He didn’t.

He struggled offensively, lost the contest comfortably and will undoubtedly have plenty to work on with his team.

However, losing to a world champion doesn’t make somebody a bad fighter.

Warburton has now experienced ten rounds against an opponent operating at a level he hadn’t previously encountered.

That experience could prove valuable as his career progresses.

He knows more about the demands of competing against elite opposition, and his team has a clearer understanding of the areas that need improvement.

Most importantly, he reached the final bell.

He doesn’t have a victory to celebrate, but he also doesn’t have a stoppage defeat to recover from.

There’s no shame in recognising that somebody is better than you.

The important thing is learning from that experience and becoming a better fighter because of it.

Carlos Adames Should Look at His Own Performance Before Criticising Warburton

Carlos Adames vs Gerome Warburton was a comfortable victory for the WBC middleweight champion.

Nobody is disputing that.

However, I find Adames’s criticism of Warburton considerably less impressive than his performance.

If he genuinely believes Warburton was so limited, so negative and so incapable of competing with him, why couldn’t he stop him?

Surely an elite world champion should possess the tools to overcome those problems?

Adames cannot have it both ways.

He cannot criticise his opponent for being incapable of competing at his level whilst simultaneously blaming that opponent for his own inability to secure a stoppage.

Warburton did what he needed to do to reach the final bell.

Adames did what he needed to do to win the contest.

The difference is that only one of them appears to be complaining about the outcome.

If you want my opinion, Carlos Adames should spend less time criticising Gerome Warburton and more time examining why he couldn’t finish the job.

Because if he was genuinely as superior as he believes, surely he should have found a way.

Over to You: Who Really Deserves the Criticism?

Was Carlos Adames justified in criticising Gerome Warburton for concentrating on survival, or should the world champion be questioning his own inability to secure a stoppage?

Is there anything wrong with a boxer recognising that victory is beyond him and concentrating on reaching the final bell?

And would we be having an entirely different conversation if Warburton had suffered a damaging knockout?

Let me know where you stand in the comments below, and share this article with your fellow boxing supporters. I’d particularly like to hear from those who agree with Adames, because I think there’s a genuinely interesting debate to be had here.

For more independent boxing opinions, honest analysis and discussions about the issues that matter to our sport, head over to CMBoxing.

Because sometimes the biggest questions in boxing aren’t about the fighter who lost, but the fighter who won.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *