Saturday night delivered one of the most electrifying female boxing matches in recent memory as Natasha Jonas edged out Mikaela Mayer in a razor-close split decision. While fans were treated to ten rounds of technical brilliance, aggression, and grit — the result has sparked a firestorm of debate: should Mikaela Mayer get a rematch?
A Fight That Had Everything — Except Closure
From the opening bell, Jonas vs Mayer was a high-quality contest. Both fighters showed why they belong at the elite level of women’s boxing, with Mayer’s slick boxing and Jonas’ explosive timing producing a captivating clash of styles.
But when the final bell rang and the split decision was announced in favour of Jonas, many — myself included — were left questioning the outcome. I had Mayer winning by three rounds, and after watching the bout again, that view hasn’t changed. Sure, Jonas landed some eye-catching shots, but in terms of consistent ring generalship and volume, Mayer edged it.
Still not sure? Watch the fight and see for yourself:
Mayer Felt Robbed — And She’s Not Alone
It’s worth noting that both women believed they’d done enough to win — and that’s telling. But Mayer’s reaction in the post-fight interviews made her feelings crystal clear: she believes she was robbed. And honestly, she may have a point. Even Natasha Jonas, classy as ever, looked slightly uncomfortable accepting the decision.
Will We See a Rematch?
In short — we should, and we probably will.
There are just too many unanswered questions for this rivalry to end here. It may not be the immediate next fight for either woman, but I’d bet on it happening before the end of the year. It likely won’t return to Liverpool either. A more neutral venue like Manchester or London could help avoid the appearance of hometown influence — something fans and pundits have already raised concerns about.
Was the crowd a factor? We’ll never know for sure, but in boxing, perception matters.
What If It Doesn’t Happen?
If the rematch falls through, expect Jonas to target a unification bout with Jessica McCaskill — a high-stakes clash that would add another chapter to her incredible career.
As for Mayer, this loss has arguably raised her stock. She boxed superbly, showed toughness, and made a statement. Don’t be surprised if she bounces back with a tune-up fight before going after her own shot at McCaskill. Should she win, a unification rematch with Jonas could headline either side of the Atlantic.
Final Thoughts: Did the Judges Get It Wrong?
That’s the question, isn’t it? Whether you had it for Mayer or Jonas, one thing is clear: this fight deserves a sequel. Women’s boxing needs rivalries like this — competitive, compelling, and packed with narrative.
So let’s hear it, fight fans: Should Mikaela Mayer get a rematch? Or did the judges get it right?
Hi Chris I agree with what you say there should be a rematch, and it should be on neutral ground. As you said it was a cracking fight cheers mate 👍