The boxing world was set ablaze when Katie Taylor vs Serrano headlined Madison Square Garden in April 2022. The fight delivered everything fans had hoped for—intensity, skill, and a razor-thin result. However, the aftermath of Taylor’s victory via split decision has sparked endless debate. Many believe Serrano did enough to win, while others argue Taylor’s cleaner shots and movement sealed the deal. Now, talks of a rematch are gaining traction, and fans are eager to see if justice will be served in the ring.
The Controversy: Did the Judges Get It Right?
Katie Taylor retained her undisputed lightweight championship in what was a historic night for women’s boxing. Yet, the scorecards left a bitter taste in the mouths of many spectators. Some analysts, including those from ESPN, felt Serrano’s aggressive pressure and high punch volume should have secured her the win. Meanwhile, others, like Boxing Scene, argued that Taylor’s superior footwork and precise counterpunching were enough to justify the judges’ decision.
The split decision (96-93 Serrano, 97-93 Taylor, and 96-94 Taylor) showcases just how close the fight was. The debate isn’t merely about who won but also about judging standards in boxing. Should aggression outweigh accuracy? Should volume surpass precision? These are questions that remain unanswered.
Why a Taylor vs Serrano Rematch is Necessary
A rematch isn’t just about settling the score—it’s about legacy. Both fighters have expressed interest in running it back, with Serrano stating on The Athletic that she is “more than ready” to avenge her loss. Taylor, on the other hand, welcomes the challenge but insists the judges made the right call.
Fans deserve to see this rivalry conclude with a definitive winner. A rematch would also further elevate women’s boxing, proving that female fighters can headline major events and deliver must-watch moments.
Where Could Taylor vs Serrano 2 Take Place?
Promoters are already eyeing potential venues. The original fight made history at Madison Square Garden, but there’s a growing push for the rematch to take place in Taylor’s home country, Ireland. Matchroom Boxing has hinted at Croke Park in Dublin as a possible location, which would make for an electric atmosphere. Alternatively, the rematch could land in Las Vegas, where big-money fights often find their home.
The Stakes Are Higher Than Ever
Both fighters have everything to gain and everything to lose. If Taylor wins again, she cements her legacy as the greatest female boxer of all time. If Serrano wins, she avenges the most controversial loss of her career and shakes up the lightweight division. With both fighters at the peak of their powers, this rematch could surpass their first encounter in terms of action and drama.
Join the Debate: What Do You Think?
Do you believe Katie Taylor deserved the win, or should Amanda Serrano have been crowned the undisputed champion? Should the rematch happen in Ireland, or would Las Vegas be the better stage? Let me know your thoughts in the comments! Whether you agree with me or not, I want to hear from you.
Also, be sure to check out more boxing coverage on CMBoxing and stay updated with the latest fight news.
Share Your Thoughts and Stay Connected!
- Comment below and share your opinion!
- Follow CMBoxing for more updates on boxing news, fight predictions, and analysis.
- Share this post with fellow boxing fans to keep the discussion going!
A rematch between Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano isn’t just about another fight—it’s about settling one of the most debated decisions in recent boxing history. Let’s keep the conversation alive!