The Fall of the Juggernaut
Joe Joyce’s career has always carried a sense of inevitability. The “Juggernaut” was supposed to roll through the heavyweight division, and for a while, he did. But the recent record tells a much bleaker story. Back-to-back defeats to Zhilei Zhang, a points loss to Filip Hrgovic, and a rough night against Derek Chisora paint the picture of a fighter on the slide rather than one charging towards a world title shot.
At 38, Joyce doesn’t just look like a fighter in decline — he looks like a fighter on borrowed time. The talk of a Joe Joyce comeback feels optimistic at best, delusional at worst.
Why Retirement Would Make Sense
Let’s be blunt. Joyce has been stopped, outboxed, and shown that his granite chin — once his calling card — can be cracked. His style has always relied on taking one to land one, but when the reflexes slow and the punishment piles up, that’s a recipe for long-term damage.
Most fans remember his thrilling win over Joseph Parker in 2022 — arguably his career high point — but since then the defeats have stacked up. For many, that was the moment to bow out gracefully. Walking away now would preserve his health, his reputation, and avoid the kind of slow decline that tarnishes too many great careers.
If Not Retirement… Then Who?
Here’s where things get tricky. If Joyce insists on continuing, the options at heavyweight aren’t exactly appealing. He’s not in line for a big title shot, and most top-10 contenders see little benefit in fighting him now.
The one fight that just about makes sense? Dillian Whyte.
Whyte is also coming off damaging defeats, including his recent brutal stoppage against Moses Itauma. Like Joyce, his stock has plummeted, and both men are in desperate need of a “last chance” narrative.
Is it world-level? No. Is it meaningful for rankings? Not really. But it is a fight that could sell in Britain as a crossroads clash — two heavyweights with nothing to lose and everything to prove. It’s also the only fight left that wouldn’t feel like a complete mismatch.
Why the Joe Joyce Comeback Still Resonates
Even with the defeats, there’s something about Joyce that fans admire. His stoic personality, his willingness to fight anyone, and his refusal to quit make him a likeable figure in an often cynical sport.
When Joyce says “there’s still plenty of good fights out there,” he’s probably wrong in terms of titles — but he’s right in spirit. Boxing loves a comeback story, even if it ends in heartbreak. And maybe that’s why people still tune in.
Final Bell
Whether he retires or takes one last swing at redemption, Joyce’s next move matters. For his health, retirement is the smart choice. For drama, a Dillian Whyte fight is the only Joe Joyce comeback worth talking about.
What do you think? Should Joyce call it a day, or do you want to see him in one final tear-up?
Share your thoughts in the comments below and check out more deep dives at CMBoxing.